Book Reviews

Book Review: The Plastic Magician


Ethel took her hand. ‘You’re a good friend Alvie. Even without all the magic.’ Alvie squeezed back. ’You are too, Ethel. Even without the arm.’ The older woman’s eyes watered just a bit. ‘I think that, today that’s something I needed to hear’.

TITLE & AUTHOR: The Plastic Magician by Charlie N. Holmberg

SERIES: The Paper Magician, #4 (spin-off)

GENRE: Fantasy/YA/Romance/Historical Fiction

PUBLISHED : May 15th 2018, by 47North

MY RATING: 3.5/5


A fun and short novel expanding the old universe

The Plastic Magician is the fourth novel in Holmberg’s The Paper Magician series, but it features different main characters and can be read as a standalone. So, you don’t need to read the trilogy, but I’d still recommend doing so, simply because the trilogy serves as a good introduction to this magical world, and because there’s more magic. The Plastic Magician is more about science.

If you’ve already read The Paper Magician trilogy, then you know what to expect – we are again thrown into the magical world at the turn of the century, where one can become a magician by bonding to a man-made material like paper, plastic, glass, etc. After the magical school, the students become apprentices under famous magicians, where they train for several years for their final exam which will make them magicians themselves. This time the heroine is Alvie Brechenmacher who comes from America to London to train as a Polymaker (plastic magician), which is not really as boring as it sounds. The original trilogy was centered on paper and glass magicians which is far more magical, as you can animate origami birds/dogs to life, or travel/communicate through mirrors, but it seems that plastics have quite a few magical uses.

This time we have a more refined plot, an interesting villain with a realistic mastermind plan, and a less whiny Mary Sue, who is quite determined not to blush in awkward situations, but can’t help it really, because she’s a woman. She is also quite determined to wear pants in early 1900s, because I’m-not-your-typical-Mary-Sue. So there are faults in this one too, yes, but you can clearly see Holmberg is getting better at writing, she just needs to work on her characters more.

What I liked the most, except a better lead character, was that there was some science involved. The main plot is about Alvie’s mentor, Magician Praff, who will be training her for several years, preparing for a scientific convention. He had an extremely successful invention and won several years ago, so now he naturally feels the need to outdo himself and create something even better. Made from plastics of course. Unexpectedly, his young student will help him on the way, but there are many scientists still bitter and jealous because of his success and some will stop at nothing to undermine his effort.

Other than Alvie and Mg. Praff, there are several side characters I really liked. Holmberg already proved she can create interesting characters, and here we can see her crafting better villains, but I think she still needs to get rid of Mary-Sues and create better heroines.

For those of you who loved the original trilogy, there are of course some surprises in store, and some returning characters.

I really enjoyed this book, and far more than the original trilogy, and I do hope there will be more. The magical system is fresh, interesting and fun, the novel is a quick and light read, and Charlie Holmberg is definitely getting better at writing, although I haven’t yet dared to try her other novels, outside of this universe. If you’re looking for a quick and fun magical read, then this is it.


Footer 3.5

19 thoughts on “Book Review: The Plastic Magician

  1. I can not wait to read this book. I also wanted you to know that I nominated you for the sunshine blogger award in my latest blog post. I think you have a gorgeous blog here.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Aw this sounds like such a neat book, and the cover is so neat! I’ve never heard of this series before, but I’ll definitely be keeping an eye out at book sales! I’ll probably start at the first novel, though. You say The Plastic Magician is better than the others… but are the others still good enough to pick up?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yep, the trilogy is nice too, light fantasy reading. 🙂 I read all 4 in just a couple of days, it reads fast, just the quality is not the focus haha. 😀 They’re fun, that’s important, but book 4 feels better written. 🙂


Say something

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s